PAL/NTSC Upgrade (PAL ANTIC in an NTSC XL/XE)
- Year
- 1995
- Type
- DIY project
- Category
- Video-standard modification
- Manufacturer
- Nir Dary (kit and documentation with Ben Poehland, 1995)
Overview
Much of the best Atari 8-bit software of the 1990s and later, especially Polish and other European games and demos, was written for PAL machines. On an NTSC Atari it often runs too fast, jitters, or crashes, because its timing assumes PAL's longer frame. Nir Dary's PAL/NTSC Upgrade (version 1.0, July 1995; documentation by Nir Dary and Ben Poehland) gave North American owners of the 600XL, 800XL, 65XE, 130XE and XE Game System a way to run that software in full colour on an ordinary NTSC TV or monitor.
It was sold as a kit containing a PAL ANTIC chip (CO21698), a replacement OS ROM, 40- and 28-pin sockets, software disks and documentation. Dary offered free installation for kit buyers, who paid shipping.
Why PAL software breaks on NTSC
| PAL Atari | NTSC Atari | |
|---|---|---|
| Fields per second | 50 | 60 |
| Lines per frame (TV standard) | 625 | 525 |
| CPU clock | 1.7734470 MHz | 1.7897725 MHz |
| Cycles per vertical blank | 35,468 | 29,829 |
| Crystals | two (separate colour clock) | one |
An NTSC frame gives a program only about 84% of the CPU time a PAL frame does. PAL demos that pack work into every frame overrun, and display-list and VBI timing goes wrong. PAL machines need a second crystal because the PAL colour carrier can't be divided out of the system clock: it would need a divide-by-2.8.
How the upgrade works
- PAL ANTIC. Replacing ANTIC makes the machine generate a 50 Hz, PAL-timed display. Colour still comes out correctly on an NTSC set, because GTIA and the colour circuitry are unchanged, but the picture is a different size.
- Patched OS. XL/XE machines use one OS for both standards and detect which they are by reading GTIA's
$D014: bits 1–3 clear means PAL, set means NTSC. The result goes into PALNTS at$62. With a PAL ANTIC but an NTSC GTIA, the OS would still report NTSC, and some PAL software checks that flag. Dary's fix is a single byte. At$C385the NTSC branch'sLDX #$00becomesLDX #$01, so$62always reads 1 (PAL). The patch also leaves the NTSC key-repeat values in place.
For owners of modified OS chips (Omnimon, Omniview, ARGS and other 27128 EPROM OSes) Dary offered to apply the same patch. For CSS's epoxy-potted UltraSpeed+ OS, which can't be read out, he supplied a BASIC routine that copies the OS to RAM, patches it and cold-starts. He found only two European programs that actually needed the patched flag.
Installation
- XLs with socketed chips: pull the NTSC ANTIC (CO12296 or CO21697) and the OS ROM (CO61598), and plug in the new chips. On the 800XL and 130XE, ANTIC is U7 and the OS is U5.
- XEs and soldered XLs: desolder ANTIC (40 pins) and the OS (28 pins) and fit sockets. The guide recommends a 15–25 W iron and a squeeze-bulb desoldering tool. Re-flow each pin with fresh solder first, then suck it clear. Check each pin is free with pliers before prying, and never force a chip: that tears traces.
- RAM-upgrade owners: if your memory upgrade has wires on ANTIC, move them. The PAL CO21698 is functionally equivalent to the newer NTSC CO21697, which is simpler to rewire than the old CO12296.
- Test on the bench: power the bare board with only video attached. If BASIC's READY doesn't appear, switch off at once and check orientation, bent pins and solder bridges.
- Afterwards, adjust your monitor's vertical and horizontal size, because the PAL picture is a different shape.
The catch: flicker
At 50 Hz the picture flickers noticeably to viewers used to 60 Hz. The guide reports that children rarely notice it and adults over 30 often object, and bright room light helps. Dary advised against fitting it to a machine used for long text work such as word processing or programming. He recommended a second machine kept for games and demos, where the moving screen hides the flicker.
Today
Emulators let you choose PAL or NTSC freely, so try a PAL title there before committing to the mod. Keep the original NTSC ANTIC and OS chips in anti-static packaging: the conversion is fully reversible on a socketed board. The OS listing above is also a neat lesson in how XL/XE software tells the two standards apart.
Credits
- Picture: The PAL ANTIC, part CO21698, that the upgrade fits into an NTSC machine. — Multicherry, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
- Nir Dary and Ben Poehland — PAL/NTSC Upgrade v1.0 documentation (7/95), Nir Dary collection — Nir Dary collection
- Frankenstein / AlphaSys — PAL and NTSC: How to get confused (Nir Dary collection) — Nir Dary collection
