Choosing a DOS for Your Atari 8-bit
An 8-bit Atari has no disk operating system in ROM. It boots whatever DOS is on the disk, cartridge or virtual drive in front of it. Over forty years that has produced dozens of DOSes. The good news is that you only need to understand a handful, and most of them share one of two disk formats.
What you'll learn: what a DOS actually is on the Atari, the two big disk-format families, the strengths and weaknesses of each major DOS, and which one to pick for your setup.
What you need: nothing beyond curiosity. Every DOS mentioned here runs in Altirra or atari800 if you want to try before committing a real disk.
1. What "DOS" means on an Atari
A disk system has several parts. Two of them are built into the OS ROM:
- SIO, the low-level serial bus routines that talk to drives.
- CIO, the device-independent I/O layer that BASIC's
OPEN,PRINT #andGET #go through.
What you load from disk is:
- the FMS (File Management System), which provides the
D:device and turns sectors into named files, and - optionally a DUP or command processor, the user interface.
Because programs talk to D: through CIO, most software works with any DOS that provides a well-behaved D: handler. Trouble comes from programs that jump directly into a particular DOS's internals, or that need the RAM a DOS occupies.
2. The two format families
| Family | DOSes | Character |
|---|---|---|
| Atari DOS 2-compatible (sector-linked files, VTOC at sector 360, 64-file directory) | DOS 2.0S, DOS 2.5, MyDOS, plus many clones (SmartDOS, TOP-DOS, SuperDOS, Bibo-DOS…) | Universal, simple, menu-driven. Read by nearly every tool and emulator |
| SpartaDOS File System (sector maps, subdirectories, time stamps, volume names) | SpartaDOS 1.1–3.2, SpartaDOS X, BW-DOS, RealDOS, Micro-SpartaDOS | Command line, subdirectories, large media |
The odd ones out are DOS 3 (Atari, shipped 1984–85), which uses 1K blocks and its own format, and DOS XE (1988), which also has its own format. Neither is compatible with the DOS 2 family, and both are best avoided unless you need to read old disks. Antic's 1988 beginner's handbook told new owners who got DOS 3 to get DOS 2.5 or 2.0 instead. Bridges exist: DOS 2.5 includes COPY32.COM to copy files off DOS 3 disks, and DOS XE includes an optional DOS 2.x file manager (drives A1:–A8:) for DOS 2.0 and 2.5 disks.
3. The main candidates
Atari DOS 2.0S (1980–81). The original standard. Single density only (707 free sectors, 88,375 bytes), two drives by default. It introduced AUTORUN.SYS and MEM.SAV, and its binary file format is used by every later DOS except DOS 1. Use it for old protected software that insists on it.
Atari DOS 2.5 (1985, by OSS for Atari). DOS 2.0S plus 1050 enhanced density (1010 free sectors), a 130XE RAMdisk on D8: and three utilities. Same menu as 2.0S, with option P (Format Single) added. The safest default for type-ins, BASIC work and casual use. See our DOS 2.5 guide.
DOS XE (© 1988, shipped from 1989; Bill Wilkinson for Atari). Shipped with late XF551 drives. Requires an XL/XE. It has a hybrid menu and command interface, batch files and subdirectories, but uses its own format. A curiosity today.
MyDOS 4.5x (Charles Marslett, Wordmark; freeware from 4.50 in 1988). DOS 2 menu and files, plus subdirectories, true double density, double-sided drives, hard disks to 65,535 sectors and RAMdisks to 1 MB. MyDOS can read DOS 2.5 enhanced disks but only writes their first 720 sectors. Pick it if you want the DOS 2 feel with big virtual disks. See our MyDOS guide.
SpartaDOS 1.1–3.2 (ICD, 1984–86; FTe 3.2g in 1994). Disk-based command-line DOS, which made the SpartaDOS File System popular. 3.2 added time/date support, a keyboard buffer and R-Time 8 support. It's largely superseded by SpartaDOS X and BW-DOS, but its disks remain readable by both.
SpartaDOS X (ICD 1988–89; FTe 1995; DLT 2006–today, 4.50 in Dec 2024). Cartridge-based, the most powerful option. Up to 15 drives, 512-byte sectors and 32 MB disks (current versions), 16 open files, batch files, I/O redirection, configurable drivers, and from 4.43 PCLink access to a PC's filesystem through servers such as RespeQt. Pick it for hard-disk, SD-card and flash-cart setups and for serious users. See our SpartaDOS X guide.
BW-DOS (BEWESOFT 1994–95; Holger Janz 2020–, 1.5 in Nov 2024). Free, disk-based, SpartaDOS File System, SpartaDOS-compatible commands. It doesn't touch extended RAM or the RAM under the OS. Pick it for SpartaDOS features without the cartridge. See our BW-DOS guide.
RealDOS (ILS, 2002–2023). Another SpartaDOS-format DOS. It needs a 64K XL/XE and supports a long list of interfaces (Black Box, MIO, SIO2PC, SIO2SD, The Multiplexer…).
4. The "mini DOS" option for games
If you just want a disk that boots into a menu of games, you don't need a full DOS at all. Three modern "game DOSes" do this:
- MyPicoDos (Matthias Reichl; 4.06 dated 1992–2017): for DOS 2.x/MyDOS disks of 720–65,535 sectors. It loads COM/EXE, BIN boot images and BAS files, with high-speed SIO up to 126 kbit/s, and switches BASIC on or off automatically on XL/XE machines.
- Micro-SpartaDOS (BEWESOFT, then Pecus and Pirx; 4.7 has source available): the same idea for SpartaDOS-format disks.
- LiteDOS-SE (Sijmen Schouten, 2018–2022): uses only 2K of RAM, reads DOS 2/2.5/MyDOS disks and boots in 2–3 seconds.
5. Quick recommendations
| Your setup | Suggested DOS |
|---|---|
| Typing in magazine listings, BASIC programming, stock 800XL/130XE with 1050 | DOS 2.5 |
| Large ATR images on SIO2PC/RespeQt, FujiNet or SD devices, DOS 2-style menu | MyDOS 4.5x |
| Hard disk, flash cartridge, lots of files, batch work | SpartaDOS X |
| SpartaDOS power on a disk, free | BW-DOS |
| Bootable game compilations | MyPicoDos (DOS 2 disks) or Micro-SpartaDOS (SpartaDOS disks) |
| Old protected software | Whatever DOS it shipped with, often DOS 2.0S |
6. Interoperability tips
- DOS 2 format is the lingua franca. SpartaDOS X reads and writes it through its ATARIDOS driver (such disks show volume name
AtariDOS). BW-DOS's MENU handles DOS 2.0 SD/DD and DOS 2.5. MyDOS reads 2.5 but writes only its first 720 sectors. - SpartaDOS X is faster on its own format. Binary loads with many segments can take many minutes longer from an AtariDOS disk, so copy programs to a SpartaDOS disk or RAMdisk first.
- Filenames: the common rules are 1–8 characters plus an optional 0–3 character extension, letters and digits, and in many DOSes no leading digit. SpartaDOS-family DOSes and DOS XE also accept
_. - Auto-run conventions differ: DOS 2.x and MyDOS run
AUTORUN.SYS(MyDOS 4.53 runs*.AR0–*.AR9instead), SpartaDOS X and DOS XE runAUTOEXEC.BAT, and BW-DOS runsSTARTUP.BAT. - Memory matters. Every DOS takes RAM. MyDOS spends 256 bytes per open-file buffer. If a big program fails to load, try a leaner DOS or a mini DOS.
Troubleshooting
- "My disk image boots but the directory looks like garbage": you're probably reading a SpartaDOS-format disk with a DOS 2-family DOS, or vice versa. Boot the matching DOS.
- Files written by DOS 2.0S on a DOS 2.5 enhanced disk vanish or corrupt: DOS 2.0S only understands the first 720 sectors. Stick to one DOS per enhanced disk.
- XL/XE won't boot a DOS disk that worked on an 800: most DOSes are fine on both, but some 400/800-only software needs the Atari Translator. That's an OS issue, not a DOS issue.
Further reading
- Inside Atari DOS by Bill Wilkinson (COMPUTE! Books / Small System Services, 1982). How the DOS 2.0S FMS works, line by line.
- The FAQ's §7.3.3 lists nearly every third-party DOS ever released, with version histories.
- Related guides: DOS 2.5 guide, MyDOS guide, SpartaDOS X guide, BW-DOS guide.
Credits
- Picture: The Atari 1050 disk drive. Which DOS suits you depends partly on the drives you own and the densities they support. — Bilby, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0)
- comp.sys.atari.8bit FAQ (Michael Current), sections 7.3.1–7.3.5 — Michael Current (comp.sys.atari.8bit FAQ)
- MYDOS Version 4 Benutzerhandbuch, Rev. 4.5 (WORDMARK Systems, 1988) — Internet Archive, 1988
- Antic Vol. 6 No. 10 (Feb 1988) — First-Time Atari Users Handbook — AtariMagazines.com (Kevin Savetz), 1988
