'The Atari 800 vs the Apple II' (1981 Dealer Training Guide)

Year
1981
Type
Computer
Category
Atari sales-training document comparing the 800 with the Apple II Plus
Manufacturer
Atari, Inc.
Typed first page headed 'The Atari 800 Personal Computer System vs The Apple II Personal Computer System' with a line drawing of an Atari 800 and introductory text

Overview

In August 1981 Atari gave its retail dealers a 20-page illustrated booklet titled "The Atari 800 Personal Computer System vs The Apple II Personal Computer System". Every page is stamped "This is a dealer training document; not intended for release to the general public." Its job was to give a salesperson answers when a customer was choosing between Atari's machine and the Apple II Plus, then the established home and school computer.

The opening sets the tone. The Apple II Plus is described as a reworked version of Apple's "original hobbyist computer". The 800, by contrast, "was conceived from the beginning to be a general purpose personal computer for the consumer market". Arriving later, it "lacks some of their early-design mistakes" and benefited from "a massive engineering research and development effort" including custom chips.

The arguments, page by page

Topic Atari 800 (as Atari presented it) Apple II Plus (as Atari presented it)
Keyboard 57 keys plus 4 special function keys; upper and lower case; graphics characters; separate cursor keys; insert and delete for characters and whole lines 52 keys; upper case only without adapters; no insert function
Memory expansion Lift the lid and plug in 8K or 16K RAM modules, up to 48K. A few seconds, chips never exposed, modules fit only one way Up to 48K by inserting individual chips into the board, with a risk of static damage, bent pins or reversed chips
Cartridges Two slots, so programs such as BASIC, Assembler Editor, Music Composer and Computer Chess run without any disk or tape None
RF shielding Designed from the start to meet FCC rules, with a heavy aluminium casting around the electronics Did not meet FCC rules before March 1981
Safety Opening the top switches the power off automatically; no electronics exposed to "wandering hands" No interlock; boards exposed when the lid is off
TV protection Built-in RF modulator; a "TV screen-protection mode" (attract mode) cycles the colours after a few idle minutes to prevent burn-in Designed for a monitor; modulator extra; no burn-in protection
Controllers Four front ports for joysticks, paddles and the light pen Paddle socket inside the case
Disk drive 810: 88K per disk, intelligent controller in the drive, one cable to connect, FCC-approved 143K per disk under DOS 3.3, faster, but a controller card must be fitted inside
Interfaces Most peripherals plug straight into SIO; the 850 adds five interfaces for about the price of one Apple card Eight internal slots; some cards up to $495
Cassette 410 recorder made for the system, automatic levels, a second audio track for voice and music (used by the Conversational language tapes) Ordinary recorders with manual level adjustment
Sound Four voices through the TV speaker, 256 notes over 3½ octaves, 16 volume levels, 8 distortions A small internal speaker; add-on sound boards are expensive
Graphics 128 colours (as stated), 3 text modes and 5 more graphics modes, up to 320×192; display list interrupts, player-missile graphics, redefinable character sets 16 colours, one text mode, low and high resolution graphics

The last page sums it up. Both machines use the 6502, but the 800 adds "three custom-designed chips", one of them (ANTIC) a microprocessor in its own right. The booklet argues that the quality of Atari software depends on that hardware.

Reading it today

This is sales material, written to win arguments, and some claims are slanted. It admits the 810 is slower and holds less than the Apple Disk II, but says the difference is "of little or no consequence to the average consumer". It plays down the Apple's internal slots, which many hobbyists valued. Still, it's an unusually direct statement of what Atari thought made the 800 different in 1981: a closed, safe, FCC-approved consumer appliance, expandable through modules, cartridges and the SIO bus. That design philosophy is described in Atari 800, 400/800 internal boards and SIO.

Credits

  • Picture: Page 1 of the August 1981 guide, marked 'not intended for release to the general public'. — First page of Atari's August 1981 dealer training document 'The Atari 800 Personal Computer System vs the Apple II Personal Computer System', scan from the local Atari documents collection