NTSC, PAL and SECAM Ataris: The Differences
- Year
- 1979
- Type
- Component
- Category
- Technical reference — television standards and regional versions
- Manufacturer
- Atari, Inc. / Atari Corp.
Overview
Every 8-bit Atari is built for one television standard: NTSC (North America and parts of South America and Asia), PAL (most of Europe, Australia and elsewhere), or SECAM (France). Because the computer's timing is derived from the colour-TV signal it produces, the standard affects much more than the picture. The CPU runs at a slightly different speed, a frame has a different number of lines and arrives at a different rate, and the custom chips come in different versions. For software, though, there are really only two families: NTSC, and PAL/SECAM.
The numbers
| NTSC | PAL / SECAM | |
|---|---|---|
| CPU clock | 1.789773 MHz (half the NTSC colour subcarrier) | 1.7734475 MHz (2/5 of the PAL subcarrier) |
| Cycles per scan line | 114 | 114 |
| Scan lines per frame | 262 | 312 |
| Cycles per frame | 29,868 | 35,568 |
| Frame rate | 59.92 Hz | 49.86 Hz |
| Vertical blank time (for an immediate VBI, with a 240-line display) | about 2,508 cycles | about 8,208 cycles |
| ANTIC | NTSC version (C012296; later "E") | PAL version ("A" in 400/800, "B" in XL/XE) |
| Colour chip | CTIA (early 400/800) or GTIA C014805 | PAL GTIA C014889; FGTIA C020120 on SECAM XL/XE |
PEEK(53268) (GTIA PAL register), bits 1–3 |
set ($0F) |
clear ($01) |
PAL B and PAL I machines differ only in their RF channel, so all PAL Ataris behave identically. The SECAM FGTIA is designed to be software-compatible with the PAL GTIA and is paired with a PAL ANTIC, with two practical exceptions: in GTIA graphics mode 9 it shows only 8 brightness levels instead of 16, and it samples the joystick trigger inputs only once per scan line (at the start of horizontal blank). Because XL/XE machines use the trigger-3 input as the cartridge-present line, that latching occasionally upsets bank-switching cartridges on SECAM machines. Not every SECAM machine has an FGTIA; some use the PAL GTIA.
What goes wrong when software crosses over
- Speed. Anything timed by the vertical blank runs about 17% slower on PAL (50 vs 60 updates per second), and PAL-timed code runs about 20% faster on NTSC. Music players are the classic casualty: an NTSC tune sounds sluggish on a PAL machine unless the player compensates. CPU-timed loops differ by only about 1%.
- Flicker or rolling. A display list designed for PAL's extra lines can ask for more than an NTSC frame has, leaving the picture unstable.
- Crashes. PAL/SECAM programs may use thousands more cycles in their vertical-blank routines than an NTSC frame allows.
- Colours. The PAL palette is similar but not identical, and the stable artifact colours of NTSC hi-res modes don't exist on PAL or SECAM.
- Deliberate refusal or copy protection. Some programs check the machine type; Penguin Software's Transylvania and The Quest are reported to fail on PAL because of timing-based protection, while Activision's Ghostbusters checks the GTIA type and adjusts itself.
The rule of thumb: American software almost always works on European machines, but software developed on PAL/SECAM machines sometimes won't work as intended on NTSC ones. Fitting a PAL ANTIC to an NTSC machine gives it 50 Hz timing for most PAL software — provided the display accepts 50 Hz.
Telling them apart in software
- XL/XE OS:
PEEK(98)(PALNTS) is 0 on NTSC and 1 on PAL/SECAM. - Any model: read GTIA's PAL register at 53268 (
$D014) and test bits 1–3. - By counting lines: ANTIC's VCOUNT (
$D40B, 54283) reaches 130 on NTSC and 155 on PAL.
10 IF PEEK(53268)=1 THEN PRINT "PAL/SECAM":END
20 PRINT "NTSC"
(The full register reads $01 on PAL/SECAM GTIAs and $0F on NTSC ones; robust code tests only bits 1–3.)
Regional variations
Beyond the three standards there were local twists: PAL N 800XLs and 65XEs converted by Argentina's distributor Skydata, a PAL-modified Peritel 400/800 for France before native SECAM machines existed (see the separate entry), and a prototype Arabic 65XE. All run standard software for their family.
Using it today
- Emulators let you switch between NTSC and PAL instantly; when a demo or game misbehaves, try the other standard first.
- Buying across regions: check the display accepts the signal (50 Hz PAL, 60 Hz NTSC), and remember SECAM machines have no RF output at all.
- Writing software: test on both, budget your vertical-blank code for NTSC's shorter blank, and adjust music tempo on PAL if it matters.
Credits
- comp.sys.atari.8bit FAQ (Michael Current) — 1.1 (timing specifications), 1.6-1.9 (chip part numbers by version), 1.12 (CTIA/GTIA/FGTIA), 7.1.10 (detecting NTSC/PAL), 8.1 (software behaviour on NTSC/PAL/SECAM) — Michael Current (comp.sys.atari.8bit FAQ)
- Altirra Hardware Reference Manual — 2.8 (cartridge sense on FGTIA), 6.1 (GTIA variants, PAL register values), 6.11 (FGTIA trigger latching) — Avery Lee (Altirra)
