NTSC, PAL and SECAM Ataris: The Differences

Year
1979
Type
Component
Category
Technical reference — television standards and regional versions
Manufacturer
Atari, Inc. / Atari Corp.

Overview

Every 8-bit Atari is built for one television standard: NTSC (North America and parts of South America and Asia), PAL (most of Europe, Australia and elsewhere), or SECAM (France). Because the computer's timing is derived from the colour-TV signal it produces, the standard affects much more than the picture. The CPU runs at a slightly different speed, a frame has a different number of lines and arrives at a different rate, and the custom chips come in different versions. For software, though, there are really only two families: NTSC, and PAL/SECAM.

The numbers

NTSC PAL / SECAM
CPU clock 1.789773 MHz (half the NTSC colour subcarrier) 1.7734475 MHz (2/5 of the PAL subcarrier)
Cycles per scan line 114 114
Scan lines per frame 262 312
Cycles per frame 29,868 35,568
Frame rate 59.92 Hz 49.86 Hz
Vertical blank time (for an immediate VBI, with a 240-line display) about 2,508 cycles about 8,208 cycles
ANTIC NTSC version (C012296; later "E") PAL version ("A" in 400/800, "B" in XL/XE)
Colour chip CTIA (early 400/800) or GTIA C014805 PAL GTIA C014889; FGTIA C020120 on SECAM XL/XE
PEEK(53268) (GTIA PAL register), bits 1–3 set ($0F) clear ($01)

PAL B and PAL I machines differ only in their RF channel, so all PAL Ataris behave identically. The SECAM FGTIA is designed to be software-compatible with the PAL GTIA and is paired with a PAL ANTIC, with two practical exceptions: in GTIA graphics mode 9 it shows only 8 brightness levels instead of 16, and it samples the joystick trigger inputs only once per scan line (at the start of horizontal blank). Because XL/XE machines use the trigger-3 input as the cartridge-present line, that latching occasionally upsets bank-switching cartridges on SECAM machines. Not every SECAM machine has an FGTIA; some use the PAL GTIA.

What goes wrong when software crosses over

  1. Speed. Anything timed by the vertical blank runs about 17% slower on PAL (50 vs 60 updates per second), and PAL-timed code runs about 20% faster on NTSC. Music players are the classic casualty: an NTSC tune sounds sluggish on a PAL machine unless the player compensates. CPU-timed loops differ by only about 1%.
  2. Flicker or rolling. A display list designed for PAL's extra lines can ask for more than an NTSC frame has, leaving the picture unstable.
  3. Crashes. PAL/SECAM programs may use thousands more cycles in their vertical-blank routines than an NTSC frame allows.
  4. Colours. The PAL palette is similar but not identical, and the stable artifact colours of NTSC hi-res modes don't exist on PAL or SECAM.
  5. Deliberate refusal or copy protection. Some programs check the machine type; Penguin Software's Transylvania and The Quest are reported to fail on PAL because of timing-based protection, while Activision's Ghostbusters checks the GTIA type and adjusts itself.

The rule of thumb: American software almost always works on European machines, but software developed on PAL/SECAM machines sometimes won't work as intended on NTSC ones. Fitting a PAL ANTIC to an NTSC machine gives it 50 Hz timing for most PAL software — provided the display accepts 50 Hz.

Telling them apart in software

  • XL/XE OS: PEEK(98) (PALNTS) is 0 on NTSC and 1 on PAL/SECAM.
  • Any model: read GTIA's PAL register at 53268 ($D014) and test bits 1–3.
  • By counting lines: ANTIC's VCOUNT ($D40B, 54283) reaches 130 on NTSC and 155 on PAL.
10 IF PEEK(53268)=1 THEN PRINT "PAL/SECAM":END
20 PRINT "NTSC"

(The full register reads $01 on PAL/SECAM GTIAs and $0F on NTSC ones; robust code tests only bits 1–3.)

Regional variations

Beyond the three standards there were local twists: PAL N 800XLs and 65XEs converted by Argentina's distributor Skydata, a PAL-modified Peritel 400/800 for France before native SECAM machines existed (see the separate entry), and a prototype Arabic 65XE. All run standard software for their family.

Using it today

  • Emulators let you switch between NTSC and PAL instantly; when a demo or game misbehaves, try the other standard first.
  • Buying across regions: check the display accepts the signal (50 Hz PAL, 60 Hz NTSC), and remember SECAM machines have no RF output at all.
  • Writing software: test on both, budget your vertical-blank code for NTSC's shorter blank, and adjust music tempo on PAL if it matters.

Credits